When Pacific Shintaido invited Master Instructor H.F. Ito to be the special guest instructor for the PacShin Kangeiko 2020, it was with a poignant sense of historical import. We knew, given Ito senseiâs plans to cut back on international travel from his home in France, that this was likely to be one of his last formal workshops in the San Francisco Bay Area.
From a position of deep respect, the PacShin boardâShin Aoki, Cheryl Williams, and Derk Richardsonârequested that Ito sensei define the curriculum theme for the two-day gasshuku, which was held at Marin Academy, San Rafael, on the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday weekend, Saturday and Sunday, January 18â19, 2020, with an additional workshop for advanced practitioners on Monday, January 20. Master Ito chose âRediscovering Kyukajo.â His intention, he explained, was to share what he described as his ânew appreciationâ of the series of nine-plus techniques fundamental to classic Shintaido Kenjutsu practice.
Asked to deliver remarks at the Sunday afternoon closing ceremony, Master Ito, true to his unpredictable nature, chose to deliver them during Saturday morningâs opening ceremony. He kept them brief. He eschewed long, nostalgic reminiscences, and quoted General Douglas MacArthurâs 1951 farewell speech to Congress: âOld soldiers never die; they just fade away.â
Over the course of three keikoâSaturday morning, Saturday afternoon, and Sunday AfternoonâMaster Ito led a dozen or so practitioners of mixed age and experience through the 14 Kyukajo techniques. Although kyu indicates that there are nine techniques, numbers three (sankajo), four (yonkajo), five (gokajo), eight (hachikajo), and nine (kyukajo) each have a basic and an advanced movement. During the general keiko on Saturday and Sunday, Master Ito taught ikkajo (one) through nanakajo (seven) and jumped over hachikajo (eight) to kyukajo (nine). He held over the more complex hachikajo for the Advanced Workshop on Monday. With different kumite partners during the three keiko, we repeated and refined our footwork and sword movements, and experienced how timing and ma are unique to different partner pairings.
In addition to guiding us in rediscovering Kyukajo, Master Ito shared his renewed understanding of three elements that are basic to formal Kyukajo practice: It should be done with the straight sword, bokuto, designed by the founder of Shintaido, Master Aoki Sensei, rather than bokken; stepping sequences all end by drawing the feet into musubidachi stance; and each kumite begins with partners bowing to each other, drawing their swords into shoko position, lifting their swords in tandem into tenso, and returning together down to shoko. The partners repeat shoko-tenso and bow at the conclusion of kumitachi, as well.
Beyond Kyukajo. On Sunday morning, with Robert Gaston serving as exam coordinator, Connie Borden as goreisha, and Ito sensei as examiner, Nicole Masters took her examâand was the next day awarded her certificateâfor Shintaido Kenjutsu Shodan. In the gap between the exam and the break for midday brunch, while Ito sensei and National Technical Council members retreated for exam evaluation, Lee Ordeman, visiting from Washington D.C., taught a fun and brisk mini keiko focused primarily on stepping practice. Between-keiko potluck brunches were hosted by Sandra Bengtsson and Robert Gaston (Saturday) and Jim and Toni Galli Sterling (Sunday). Michael Sheets was the videographer for the gasshuku and documented every step of Ito senseiâs teachingâboth for posterity and for the eventual production of edited segments for study.
At the conclusion of the general Kangeiko on Sunday, PacShin presented Ito sensei with two gifts in gratitude for his teaching and invaluable contributions to the cultivation of Shintaido in the Bay Area over the past forty-six yearsâa beautiful bokuto/bokken cover stitched from upcycled fabrics by Nao Kobayashi, and a hard-bound book of historical photographs and written tributes from Shintaido practitioners who benefited from Master Itoâs teaching in the Bay Area. The true gifts, however, have moved in the other direction: They are the knowledge, wisdom, and practices, all of which carry over into everyday life, which Master Ito has bestowed on us all.
Le travail dâune vie, la conclusion de ma formation continuelle en Shintaido, un cristal / reflection de Kaiho-Kei Shintaido, Yoki-Kei Shintaido, Shintaido Bojutsu et Shintaido Karate.
Starting in 1989, I studied with Master Obata three or four times a year, about a week at a time, for three years. I thought I was there to learn test cutting, but I ended up also practicing Yoshinkan Aikido and Kenjutsu. At that point he called his style Toyama-Ryu Battojutsu, which was the kind of training that was taught to Japanese Army officers during wartime. Very practical â scary practical, actually ! In Los Angeles, Master Obata had a small Aikido dojo, but his teaching was so demanding that he was not very successful with his dojo. When I first started to study with him, he didnât speak English very well, and was very frustrated with his American students. He complained, âThey have no guts, no manners, and no concentration !â Of course, I know how to study from Japanese masters, so he shared a lot with me. It was like a brain dump â all of his frustration, but all of his technical skills in Aikido and Kenjutsu, too. He taught me a lot, but he was very tough on me â I would be black and blue all over after working with him for a week. He would whack me with his practice stick whenever I left an opening. We were practicing kata, and from his perspective he wasnât hitting me â he was teaching me. But he couldnât treat his American students like that because they would sue him. And Master Aoki had introduced me to him as a 20-year practitioner and his best student. So, he was very generous, but also very challenging. And, of course, this wasnât kendo with a lot of armor â we didnât have any kind of protection. I guess I had become proud again ! So, this was a good lesson, too.
J. Philip Newell writes âThe passion of the Celtic mission lay in finding meaning in the heart of all life, a sense of wonder in relation to the elements, to recognize the world as the place of revelation, and the whole of life as sacramental. The western isles developed a rich treasure of prayers that referenced the sun, moon and stars as graces, and the spiritual coming through the physical. God is seen as the Life within all life. The Celtic crosses, triangulated knots, and illuminated texts incorporated designs that symbolized the interlacing of God and humanity, heaven and earth, spirit and matter.â1
I see clear parallels here with the mystical and anthropomorphic aspects of Shintaido. Aoki Sensei quotes sword master Sekiun to the same point: âWe call the highest level which could be attained sei or âholinessâ. This realm is yuiitsu muni- just as the sun is one and the moon is one. It is the highest and the holiest.â2
As Michael Thompson Sensei wrote in the Introduction to the Shintaido handbook, âWhere does the body end and the mind or spirit begin? He (the budoka) is a specialist of that invisible and yet very physical part of ourselves which our doctors have not yet discovered. His âtreatmentâ is to teach us to communicate with our deeper selves, with each other, with nature and with God through the medium of our bodiesâ.3
One of the sacred practices we did on the retreat was to walk a stone labyrinth, situated on a peaceful hillside between a towering waterfall and a pristine sandy beach. Unlike a maze, a labyrinth has only one way in and one way out, but is nevertheless replete with surprising turns and discoveries. As one enters, you set an intention, and then just perform the movement with sincerity, trusting that when you finish, a clarity will arise upon emerging. Or as Aoki Sensei has said, âThe locus of one swing of the sword is itself a signâ.4
1) J. Philip Newell, Listening to the Heartbeat of God, p. 3, Paulist Press. 2) Haroyuki Aoki, Shintaido, p. 31, Shintaido of America. 3) ibid, p. 12. 4) ibid , p. 35.
Springtime in New England means many things. For Shintaido Northeast (SNE) it has come to mean âSpringeikoâ â a gasshuku to welcome the return of warmer weather and outdoor practice. This year, like last year, we met in South Deerfield. However, unlike last year, this year we had to deal with the absence of our beloved Joe Zawielski. The loss of Joe, who was often SNE’s Director of Instruction for gasshuku, and a mainstay of SNE, has left us facing some major shifts. We decided to have a meeting over the Saturday night potluck to think about new directions.
At lunchtime, three questions were proposed for our unconscious minds to ponder during the afternoon keiko. After dinner, we looked at our individual responses. The two fundamental themes that emerged are community and a holistic practice. But rather than interpreting these responses, they have been collated here. I invite you to think about how you would answer these questions for yourself.
What did Shintaido give you when you first encountered it, and what did you bring to it
What does Shintaido give you now â and what do you give to Shintaido?
What do you hope Shintaido can give you in the future â and what do you envision you could contribute to Shintaido?
What did Shintaido give you when you first encountered it?
A new universe to explore, and a willingness to do so. An opening for a new way to look at the world
Energy â and lots of it! Vitality!
Beginnerâs mind and fresh eyes
An excitement about lifeâs journey and a new lens to look at it through.
Showed me the whole body-mind-spirit connection.
Strong legs and a wonderfully toned body. Sore thighs. A broken nose!
A completely new way to be with my body. I was able to feel (and be) strong, graceful, capable.
An opportunity to learn that my body was more than just flesh and blood and bones â that there was whole being who encompassed also memory, spirit, energy and will. This was news to me at the time.
A community of people. Community is fundamental to Shintaido. Fun, laughter. Welcome. A sense of belonging.
A place where it was important to express all of myself, and not have it be viewed as âtoo much.â
An outlet for self-expression and extension of oneâs interest into a bigger realm.
Big nature: Ocean Beach, Tennessee Valley, Golden Gate ParkâŠHard practice on the beach in the cold and not-so-cold, but being one with the beach and cold and the others practicing.
A sense of community and a practice to develop and work on.
It challenged me to open my body and heart and spirit. Physical, mental and existential challenge. It gave me many, many opportunities to challenge myself.
Stress relief. Bright, shining world.
The thought of âWow! This is pretty neat stuff.â
It gave me a different way of connecting with my undergraduate students.
Shintaido gave me hope for extending a truncated life, being more expressive, feeling more deeply.
It gave me license to be weird, and made my body stronger.
It gave me a lot of challenges â for years I felt that I would never improve; I was just terrible at it. So it gave me difficulty, and that intrigued me, I think it kept me coming back.
What did I give, in the beginning?
Commitment and enthusiasm. Back then, I gave it my enthusiasm, going to as many classes as I could. My time, as an eager student.
A lot of energy, interest, and thought.
I gave an injection of foreign perspective to French Shintaido practitioners.
A level of participation both in and out of keiko.
Perseverance â it took a long time to âgetâ certain movements.
I gave Margaret Guay a student!
Not so long after starting, I volunteered to serve as SOA treasurer, SNE board member, etc.
What does Shintaido give you now?
It gives me an indomitable spirit. When I do the movement, even it is only ten-part meditation, I am reminded of the many instances when the body was weak but the spirit was willing. And thereâs also a sense of community that is, I think, a vital part of Shintaido.
A place to start over.
Rebirth, new beginning.
A different perspective and philosophy.
Energy!
A community of people. (Several peple said this in different ways.)
Connections that go back a very long way.
Knowledge to share in my own voice and in my own way (example: teaching at Senior Center)
The confidence and expertise that comes from doing something for more than 40 years.
A wholeness of spirit.
It still gives me community and a practice to work on. But Shintaido also helps me grow spiritually, and it provides a form for me to express my physical self with.
It gives me a community of people I have known and done something with for more than half my life, and friendship â or really, more like family.
When I practice with others, it give me energy and joy.
It gives me a depth of contact with myself, my body, my spirit that I can count on, and that I can find when I need it.
Now I know how to relax, and how to deepen.
Shintaido provides a form for me to play with physical expressions in nature. It also provides what has grown into a long-lived community of friends.
One can understand the value of Shintaido in Jungian terms â that it allows us to grasp our shadow and bring it forth in creative and constructive ways if the forms are allowed their full spiritual breadth, depth and energy. But it is still shadow and can overwhelm and even terrify people (I think this is really why people stop.) It can also put people into a frustrating tension if it is dampened by focus on linear hierarchy or mere from, since the spirit understands its bounded nature, senses the great sky. Of course this is easy and in some ways formulaic thinking in the part of someone who has lived in the more visceral tension of shadow-fear for a lifetime! Thatâs my rant!
It continues to give me a way of thinking about my body as embodied spirit, which is helpful in my current situation.
It gives me connection. Ten, chi, jin. It gives me a remote connection to others, and a spiritual practice.
A door into Japanese culture that enlarges my understanding of their art, film and literature.
A chance to reconnect with other practitioners, some of whom are close (or closer than) family. It also reminds me of the physical person I used to be, and even though Iâll never get back there. I am more aware than many people about whatâs going on in my body.
An embodiment and practice of a life philosophy.
A framework in which to continually question evaluate, and reconsider my choices in life, and a way to work through them with a very valued physical, mental and spiritual practice.
What do you give to Shintaido now?
Love.
I still volunteer on the SOA and SNE board.
Iâm not currently practicing, but Iâm on the SOA and SNE boards.
A desire to contribute to Shintaidoâs ongoing existence.
48 yearsâ experience.
Some tribal knowledge.
Lots of sharing and work at the organizational level of the Shintaido community.
What do you hope Shintaido will give you in the future?
As I am aging, I trust it will continue to support me throughout my life journey. And I also see that the physical part is less, and the spiritual is more.
Community, continued community.
I hope Shintaido will continue to provide this community that gets together throughout the year on different levels.
I hope that it will help to keep me healthy physically and mentally.
An option to share knowledge and movement in my own way separate from the Shintaido hierarchy.
A changing practice that will sustain me even as I become less able to execute physically challenging movements.
I hope it continues into the future. I worry that it will become extinct.
I hope to get back to teaching and possibly giving Shintaido retreats and classes at other venues.
In the future I plan to continue practicing as best I can despite aging. I hope my practice and insight will deepen.
Vitality!
A legacy to pass on/lineage.
Continued enjoyment with sword!
In-home services for the elderly? I expect there will always be some kind of practice for me if I continue to stay in touch with Shintaido. But there will always be the core movements of Shintaido that have kept me well in spirit over many years. Simply doing tenshingoso in the morning or evening or maybe both helps me to maintain an attitude of gratefulness, humility and wonder.
What do you hope you can contribute to Shintaido in the future?
Presence.
I hope to share more through teaching.
Continued time and commitment to practice and share Shintaido with others.
I will continue to volunteer as best I can during a big transition in life.
What I give is my most sincere effort in keiko, and I try to bring what Iâve learned to other aspects of my life.
Iâd like to contribute to planning special events, like Anne-Marieâs memorial in Montreal, and special classes with James Cumming.
After we had reflected and written in silence for several minutes, people were asked to come up with two sets of ideas to share: one abstract, and one concrete. Perhaps youâd like to do the same? Here are the combined lists from SNE Springeiko 2019:
Seeds of Change
Concepts
Vitality!
Community
Branding
Tribal knowledge
Expression!
Integration of physical and spiritual self
Embodied spirituality
LOVE
Practice of opening body and heart
Evolution
Relationships
Health
Bring one new person each (1 + 1 = 2; would double our group)
Concrete (something weâd like to see happen within the next two years)
Letâs collaborate with thriving organizations!
âCollaborative teachingâ
Hold a longer gathering with multiple teachers
Bring keiko up to Bill Burtis!
Collaborative workshop on âmindful movementâ with EMI (Judy Tso)